Back to Top

 Skip navigation

Section 6: Disability Measurement in CSO Surveys

Section 6: Disability Measurement in CSO Surveys

CSO Standards for Data Collection

The CSO has a duty, laid out in the Statistics Act 1993, to collect, analyse and disseminate information about the social, economic and general activities of the state. In addition, in relation to disability data, under Article 31 of the UNCRPD, Ireland is obliged to collect appropriate information, including statistical and research data, to develop and implement policies in line with the Convention ​[13]​. Article 31 states that: 

“Parties undertake to collect appropriate information, including statistical and research data, to enable them to formulate and implement policies to give effect to the present Convention.”

The main differences between the CSO and other data providers are our legal standing, rigorous quality controls, and stringent regulation. The steps we take to gather, analyse, and publish information allows the CSO to call the statistics produced “Official Statistics”. However, for Official Statistics to be of value, they must be trusted. This is particularly important when collecting sensitive data like disability. Achieving and maintaining trust requires that statistics are produced in an objective, transparent and independent manner.  

Codes of practice for Official Statistics are a set of principles to protect trust. The statistics produced by the CSO are regulated by the principles set out in the European Statistics Code of Practice (ESCoP) ​[35]​ and in the Irish Statistical System Code of Practice (ISSCoP) ​[36]​. The purpose of ESCoP and ISSCoP is to ensure the quality and credibility of the data underpinning Official Statistics. The principles refer to, among other things, professional independence, the protection of confidentiality, the reliability of the results, their precision, timeliness, punctuality, accessibility, clarity, comparability and coherence. There is meaningful overlap between these principals and those laid out in the UN-published guidance note on a Human Rights-Based Approach to Data collection and disaggregation ​[37]​.   

The CSO is also mandated to coordinate the effective use of data across the Irish Public and Civil Service, and to provide evidence and insight, supporting the right to live in an informed society. Coordinating the use of data for evidence and insight also supports policy development, targeted evaluation and improved public service delivery. As part of its increasing role in the stewardship of data across the Irish Public and Civil Service, the CSO provides diverse supports and services including guidance on data standards and classifications ​[38]​. As chair of the NDI, the CSO are responsible for promoting data standards across the civil and public sector. This role is strengthened under the National Equality Data Strategy, as per Action 3.1 ​[3]​, the “CSO will act as lead in the development, maintenance, and promotion of harmonised standards around classifications, providing guidance, follow-up training and support and technical advice for harmonisation”. The National Equality Data Strategy specifically highlights that data on disability is collected often, but a standard definition is not used. There is an opportunity for the upcoming IDS to support the CSO’s coordinating role, to bring increased harmonisation to disability measurement.  

CSO Approaches to Disability Measurement

The CSO produces data on disability across a range of surveys. This includes the 5-yearly Census of Population and several household surveys, including a dedicated health survey; the Irish Health Survey (IHS). See Appendix 1 for a summary of the current approaches taken to measuring disability across CSO population and household surveys.  

Global Activity Limitation Indicator

CSO household surveys, such as the EU Survey on Income and Living Conditions (SILC) and the Labour Force Survey (LFS), amongst others, are regulated under the IESS framework, which specifies core variables, domains, periodicity and technical requirements for EU social statistics, including disability statistics.  

The GALI measure of disability examines the number of people experiencing long-lasting limitations in their usual activities, because of health problems. CSO household surveys such as SILC, LFS, IHS and others, who operate under the IESS framework, utilise GALI as the core measure of disability.  

When administering GALI, CSO household surveys typically use a routed two-question format, which was identified as being easier for respondents to understand, particularly in telephone interviews and in self-administered questionnaires. This approach is in line with Eurostat’s implementing guidelines for standardised key social variables ​[39]​.  

Despite the standardisation in data collection, the results across the EU still show significant differences across member states. A recent report, comparing statistical data on disabled people across the EU, specifically noted that the number and sequence of questions is important, as the question preceding GALI may impact responses to GALI itself ​[40]​. The age limits defined for each survey will also affect comparability (for example, individuals aged 16 years and over included in SILC, compared to aged 15 year and over in the LFS). Comparability challenges are expanded upon in further sections of this report. 

See Appendix 2 for the use of GALI across a sample of CSO household surveys. 

Washington Group Short Set and Adaptions

While the three-yearly health module in the SILC collects WG-SS in its original form, other CSO household surveys typically use either the Census adaption of WG-SS, or the Budapest Initiative adaption of WG-SS ​[41]​.  

The adaption of the WG-SS for use in the Census of Population originated from Census Advisory Group (CAG) recommendations. The CAG is a group made up of representatives of Government departments, public bodies, the social partners, research institutes and CSO personnel. Their remit is to assist the CSO in the framing of the Census questionnaire ​[42]​. The Census of Population uses a question set adapted from the WG-SS and measures two disability concepts:  

  1. Long-lasting conditions or functional difficulties, and the extent to which they are experienced
  2. Impact of these conditions and functional difficulties on participation in basic activities   

The Census question set on disability has been substantially revised over the years, based on CAG recommendations, and therefore time-series is not directly comparable (see Appendix 3).  

The Census question set is the disability measure typically used in other CSO household surveys. The decision to use the Census set of questions across the CSO household surveys is based on stakeholder recommendations from an internal CSO research review on disability in 2019. The National Statistical Board further recommends that the Census question set be incorporated, as far as practicable, into all survey data collection ​[43]​.  

While the wording of the Census and the household survey questions on disability are aligned, differences in comparability continue to arise, particularly when examining some of the parameters and filtering for the second question on impact. The differences in filtering applied in the second question on impact is likely to affect the comparability of disability data from household surveys and the Census. The effect on comparability is further affected by the specific inclusion of conditions due to old age in the Census, an approach that is not followed by the LFS. It is also worth noting that this second census question was not adapted from the WG-SS, although it does include self-care.  

The IHS is unique again in its approach to measuring disability. The IHS questions are regulated under the European Health Interview Survey (EHIS) ​[44]​ and come from the Budapest Initiative, another adaption of WG-SS. The Budapest Initiative set similarly measures functional limitations. However, IHS collects data that is more specific around each functional difficulty, with additional detail, instructions and routing that does not appear in the other CSO household surveys. 

See Appendix 4 for the use of WG-SS and the WG-SS adaptions to measure disability across a sample of CSO population and household surveys.

Other Disability Indicators

As the IHS is a dedicated study of public health, it can examine health and disability to a level of detail that could not be achieved in general household surveys, or in the Census of Population. Additional disability and health indicators collected in the IHS include: 

  • Difficulties with socialising, emotional distress, sensory overload, and accepting changes to routine. 
  • The IHS approach to measuring the impacts on basic activities is quite different to that seen in other CSO surveys, for example, in depth, range, presentation of questions and response options (instructions, sequencing and wording). IHS asks about difficulty with activities of daily living (ADLs) and difficulties with instrumental activities of daily living (IADLs). 
  • The Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-8), 8-item depression screener, was selected as the instrument to monitor mental health difficulties via the IHS. 
  • The questions on measuring bodily (physical) pain comes from SF-36vTM 2 Health Survey © 1996, 2000 by Quality Metric Incorporated and Medical Outcomes Trust. They focus on the intensity of bodily pain and the extent pain interfered with normal work. 
  • Specific illnesses and conditions are also collected, as well as diagnostic data on neurodivergent conditions. 

Detail on the additional health and disability-related indicators included in the IHS is available on the CSO website ​[45]​. 

The Irish Disability Survey

The disability measure that will be used in the planned IDS will be based on a social-relational model, as it is consistent with the international standards for disability measurement in Official Statistics. The questions are being developed by the CSO, based on the extended Washington Group question sets, and in collaboration with individuals with lived experience. The IDS screening questions will be piloted online in Q4 2026 and with field interviewers in Q1 2027. The questions will then be refined and finalised ahead of the main data collection in 2028.  

When developing the IDS, the CSO are considering factors such as

  • how to meet the increasing user demand for information on specific conditions while maintaining alignment with international standards.
  • balancing the need for richer information on support needs and barriers to participation against respondent burden. 
  • preserving consistent time series in the context of questionnaire and mode changes.  
  • managing the trade-offs between international comparability and national relevance.  

Addressing these challenges will be critical to the successful design and implementation of the planned IDS and overall survey relevance. More generally, there is an opportunity for the IDS to support the CSO’s coordinating role, to bring increased harmonisation to disability measurement. It is important that the DRDAG, and the NDI group more generally, support harmonisation of disability measurement across the Irish Public and Civil Sector. Further detail on the consultation phase and the proposed content for the IDS pilot is detailed in the Pre-pilot Report ​[46]​ and in the survey webpage ​[47]​. 

Comparability and Methodological Challenges

The information provided in this section of the report details differing approaches taken to measure disability in the CSO. Each approach has its merits and limitations that require careful consideration when comparing disability prevalence from different questions sets. It is important for data users to understand why different questions sets may result in different prevalence estimates. Here we give detail on the methodological challenges that arise when collecting and comparing disability data.  

Differences across CSO data collections arise for many reasons, such as:

  • population coverage; for example, inclusion or exclusion of communal establishments, such as nursing homes 
  • survey mode; paper, interviewer led (CAPI), online (CAWI), or by telephone (CATI) 
  • question wording and sequencing of questions
  • filtering and routing rules
  • use of proxy respondents

It is widely accepted that any differences in wording can have an impact on prevalence rates and comparability across data collections, which can be further impacted by differences in mode of collection. In its guidelines for interviewers, the Washington Group highlighted that even “minor variations in question wording can lead to a significant response variation, that is, responses that do not meet the intent of the question” ​[48]​. These guidelines further advised that “standard rules in interviewing should be followed to avoid biased answers and to ensure comparability of data.”  

More recently, data analyses conducted by the Washington Group on surveys that used the Child Functioning Module clearly show that reducing the number of questions results in significant drops in the percentage of children identified as having functional difficulties ​[49]​.  

The inclusion of proxy responses can also affect comparability. Eurostat analysis of the 2011 LFS results looked at whether proxy use affected results, especially those concerning longstanding health problems and basic activity difficulties ​[50]​. It found that proxy use may affect the answers given by those surveyed as it seemed that people who responded on behalf of another household member tended to minimize longstanding health problem or a functional difficulty. It concluded that disability is usually under-reported in proxy interviews. 

A recent EU study in 2024, on the comparability of statistical data on disabled people across the EU highlighted that the exclusion of persons living in communal establishments may further bias results, particularly for older persons and disabled people ​[40]​. Conversely, the study also acknowledged the challenges around including persons living in communal settings. Such challenges include, legal issues concerning the right to interview residents, the selection of mediators for proxy interviews, where, for example, the interviewee has communication limitations, and sample selection challenges. 

Looking at the current usages within the CSO, there are differences in approach which make comparisons more difficult at national level, and at international level. Use of the Census question set on conditions and functional difficulties is not directly comparable with the WG-SS. Instead, the Census questions more closely align with national stakeholder requirements. These issues complicate both national analysis and international reporting and must be considered when interpreting disability statistics.  

See Table 1 below for a comparison of disability measurement across a selection of CSO population and household surveys. These factors should be considered when comparing disability prevalence across different surveys and different disability question sets. 

Table 1: Comparison of Disability Measurement in Main CSO Population and Household Surveys 

Survey Characteristics 

 

Census 2022 

LFS Q2 2025 

SILC 2022 

IHS 2025 

Age range 

 

All 

15+ 

16+ 

15+ 

Residence Types 

 

All persons (including communal establishments) 

Private households 

Private households 

Persons in private households 

Sample 

 

Census ­– 5+ million

Clustered sample; Probability Proportional to Size (PPS) and Simple Random Sample (SRS) – c32,500 households 

Stratified Simple Random Sample – c9,600 households

Stratified Simple Random Sample – c24,000 persons

Mandatory or voluntary 

 

Mandatory 

Voluntary 

Voluntary 

Voluntary 

Regulation 

 

S.I. No. 637/2020 ​[51]​ 

IESS ​[32]​ 

IESS ​[32]​ 

IESS ​[32]​ 

Delivery Mode 

 

Paper

CAPI & CATI 

CAPI & CATI 

CAWI, plus a small number of CAPI and CATI interviews 

Periodicity 

 

5-yearly 

Quarterly (Wave 3 only) 

3-yearly 

Annual 

GALI 

Question text 

 

GALI  

GALI 

GALI 

 

Sequencing in health block 

GALI is not used

 

A question on general health follows question on conditions or difficulties

GALI precedes included with partial MEHM

 

Question on general health precedes question on conditions or difficulties

GALI included with full MEHM

 

Question on general health precedes question on conditions or difficulties

GALI included with full MEHM

 

Question on general health precedes question on conditions or difficulties. 

Additional question on mental health included

A. 

Conditions & functional difficulties  

Question intro text 

Census adaptation of WG 

Census adaptation of WG 

WG-SS 

Budapest Initiative 

 

Question wording 

Census adaptation of WG 

Census adaptation of WG 

WG-SS 

Budapest Initiative 

 

Response options 

Census adaptation of WG 

Census adaptation of WG 

WG-SS 

Budapest Initiative 

B. 

Impact of conditions and functional difficulties on basic activities 

Filtering 

No filtering 

Only respondents who replied “to some extent” or “to a large extent” to the question on conditions or functional difficulties

 

Respondents aged 55+ or individuals who responded “Severely” or “Limited, but not severely” to GALI

 

Question intro text 

Includes conditions of old age 

 

 

ADLs and IADLs 

 

Question wording 

 

Same as Census 

 

ADLs and IADLs 

 

Response options 

 

Same as Census 

 

ADLs and IADLs