Back to Top

 Skip navigation

Section 3: Conceptual Models of Disability

Section 3: Conceptual Models of Disability

Disability has been described using different conceptual models. Each of these models share the view that disability is a word to describe a restriction in a person’s ability to participate and be included in societal life. However, each of these models differ, to varying degrees, in their viewpoints on the nature, positionality and underlying cause of the reduced capacity to participate in society. We outline below three of the most prominent types of disability models; the historical medical model, the social model, and the now commonly used social-relational model.  

The Medical Model of Disability

The medical model of disability is a view that disability is caused by some pathology that results in a loss of physical, psychological, sensory, or cognitive functioning. According to this view, a person’s reduced capacity to participate in society, which can be called disability, is caused entirely by this loss of function, and in turn, by the underlying pathology. Pathologies in this instance, could be any biomedical impairment, disease or other health condition, or a difficulty that does not fall within a diagnostic category, but which reduces a person’s ability in one or more domain. It assumes that all and any limitations have a biological origin.  

Unlike other models discussed in this report, the medical model is not a formally developed or proposed conceptualisation. This means that nobody has written about this model and proposed it is the correct and current way in which disability should be understood. Rather it is best understood as a political concept used to critique historical practices and norms within the medical profession and their role in creating a certain conceptualisation of disability.   

The medical model positions disability as something that resides internally within an individual. There are no external, social or environmental, causes of disability. The model is sometimes referred to, for this reason, as the individual model of disability ​[15]​​ [16]​. According to this model, a person’s impairment is assumed to require intervention, for instance, through medication, medical procedures, prostheses, rehabilitation or other medical devices. The assumption stems from combining the viewpoint that reducing disability is a universally desirable outcome and that disability reduction is only achievable by treating or curing the underlying pathology. It does not consider the role of personal, societal or institutional attitudes, policies or laws, to reduce experienced disability. It also does not focus on the organisation of the built or social environment to ensure that they accommodate the needs of people with these conditions to reduce disability. A consequence of these norms was that medical doctors held a large amount of power and control over disabled people’s lives. 

The medical model of disability, described by disability rights activists as the dominant model through which disability was understood from the late 1800s, was criticised as being either insufficient or oppressive ​[15]​​ [17]​. In the first instance, critics argued that what they referred to as the medical model was too narrowly focused on biological pathology. Psychiatrist George Engel argued that medicine needed to incorporate family and other social relationships, psychological adjustment and work to more fully understand health ​[17]​.  

In terms of the medical model being oppressive, disability rights activists and the disability rights movement in the 1980s argued that the placing of power to define disability and control large areas of disabled people’s lives in the hands of the medical profession was a form of oppression. They noted it had caused great harm to disabled people. This type of criticism was levelled by the proponents of what has become known as the social model of disability, outlined in more detail below. 

The ideas of George Engel, described above, later became known as the biopsychosocial model of illness ​[18]​. This biopsychosocial model is the prevailing model currently used to understand health, its determinants and its consequences, which can include disability, by both the medical profession and other healthcare professionals in modern healthcare systems. The medical model of disability is no longer used in medical practice. It is an historical construct ​[15]​. In modern health and social care, disability is co-defined by multiple types of professionals, together with disabled people, as a complex interaction between biological, psychological and social processes. While historical context undoubtedly has an influence, professionals in these contexts no longer believe disability to be entirely explained by biology or pathology. Some disability advocates have also drawn attention to the fact that many disabled people value the medical care they receive ​[19]​, for example, medication for ADHD, an autistic person using a communication device, or an amputee using prostheses. For these people, it is important the use of the phrase medical model to critique historic practices is not misapplied in ways that could be interpreted that medical care is never welcome by disabled people. It is important that conceptualisations of disability retain and protect disabled people’s autonomy to choose if they want to access medical, or other healthcare, interventions to reduce their impairments, and their disabling effects.  

Measuring disability in a survey using this approach would include, for example, asking people to report which, if any, health conditions, diseases or diagnoses they have or, depending on the context, previously had. Responses to this question would then be used to categorise people who report certain conditions as disabled. This approach is problematic on several grounds. There is not a one-to-one mapping between having a health condition and being disabled; some disabled people do not have any diagnoses and people with certain diagnoses are not necessarily disabled. Further, people who share a single diagnosis may differ with respect to disability status, for instance, one person with epilepsy may be disabled by it and another may not be. There is no definitive and agreed list of which conditions confer disability status and which do not. The number of types and subtypes of health conditions is very large and asking about all conditions in a survey is not feasible. Finally, this model of disability does not map onto how disability is understood in current practice or service delivery.

The Social Model of Disability

The social model of disability emerged from the disability rights movement. The work of the Union of the Physically Impaired Against Segregation (UPIAS) in the United Kingdom is regarded as making important early contributions to the thinking behind this model. A now seminal pamphlet called the Fundamentals of Disability details an exchange between UPIAS and the Disability Alliance, a since disbanded federation of over 250 organisations, who jointly campaigned for a Comprehensive Disability Income Scheme in the UK. In this pamphlet, UPIAS say:

“In our view, it is society which disables physically impaired people. Disability is something imposed on top of our impairments by the way we are unnecessarily isolated and excluded from full participation in society. Disabled people are therefore an oppressed group in society.”  ​[20]​ (page14, Fundamentals of Disability)

The central argument in this pamphlet is that it is the way in which society is organised, including instances where non-disabled people fail to make accommodations for people with impairments, that creates social barriers to participation and inclusion and, therefore, disability. The argument put forward was that physical impairment, which is not precisely defined in this pamphlet, is not in and of itself disabling. Instead, their position is that disability is a concept, separable from a person’s impairment, that is caused by disablism, a form of discrimination against people who have impairments ​[16]​. The thinking contained in this pamphlet laid the groundwork for the social model of disability, a term which was coined by Mike Oliver, a British sociologist and disability rights activist, who formalised this model in a 1983 book ​[21]​. Oliver extends the position of UPIAS by formally naming and describing the social model of disability and reinforces the idea that an impairment, which by Oliver’s definition, can be physical, sensory or cognitive, should be distinguished from disability, which refers to the social, attitudinal and physical barriers that society imposes upon people with these impairments. 

An important point to note is that the social model of disability does not dispute that impairments exist and indeed that they matter in the context of disability, the argument is instead that the impairments are not the cause of the disability ​[17]​. The logical conclusion of the premise put forward in this model is that a person with a given impairment will not be disabled so long as the appropriate accommodations are made for their impairment. Consider, for example, a wheelchair user who seeks access to a multistorey building, when access to the building itself and movement between floors in the building is via ramps or elevators this person is not disabled. However, if access to the building or the ability to move between floors requires the use of steps this person is then disabled by the decisions taken by those who constructed and operate the building. These decisions, according to this view, are a form of oppression. 

This model has been a powerful tool in advocating for environmental changes to improve access for people with impairments to participate and be included in their communities and societies. The model has brought about these changes through social, political and institutional reform that was made possible by shifting public perspectives about the primary cause of disability to the external environment and away from individual characteristics ​[18]​. 

Survey questions adopting a social model of disability, in its purest sense, would ask people if they, firstly, have an impairment and secondly, if they have experienced limitations in their ability to participate in certain activities on account of impairment-related oppression from people, groups or organisations. People would only be categorised as disabled if they report both. For example, someone reports tetraplegia and reports a limitation in their ability to participate in certain activities because people chose to have these activities happen in inaccessible buildings. This approach can be useful if you seek to measure disablism, that is, the specific form of discrimination experienced by disabled people on account of their impairments. Measuring the presence or magnitude of disablism has value for monitoring performance of a country in respect to its human rights and equality obligations and policies. This approach, however, does not provide for the possibility that someone could be categorised as disabled based on having a specific impairment and reporting a limitation in their ability to participate in certain activities that, in their view, is a consequence of the impairment itself. For example, a person reporting cognitive difficulties who also reports a limitation in their ability to participate in activities, such as a specific form of employment, would not be considered disabled if they attribute this limitation to their difficulties and not to societal oppression. This disability measurement approach may limit the use of the resultant data in determining where effort should be expended on reducing the disabling effects of impairments. 

An alternative disability concept, associated with Amartya Sen and Martha Nussbaum, is called the capabilities approach to disability ​[22]​​ [23]​. It focuses neither on what impairments someone may have, nor on what barriers exist for them, but rather it focuses on the capabilities someone needs to achieve things they value in life. Examples of capabilities could include, for example, securing employment, valuable relationships, being active citizens and participating in democratic processes or living independently. This view has been formalised in what is now known as the human development model of disability ​[24]​. Importantly, capabilities, in this view, are defined relative to the individual so there is no single threshold of capability that can be used to measure ability or disability at a group level according to this conceptualisation.  

The Social-Relational Model of Disability

The third model of disability, which emerged from criticisms of both the medical and social models, is often referred to as a social-relational model of disability. As discussed above, the medical model is criticised for its exclusive focus on pathology and lack of consideration for social factors. Criticisms of the social model of disability centre on the position that disability is caused entirely by disablism (structural or social barriers). Prominent disability rights advocate Carol Thomas ​[25]​ who advocated for a social-relational understanding of disability, argued that disability is caused by the limitations in a person’s functioning (impairments), by environmental and social barriers that may limit their participation in society (disablism) and, importantly, by the relationship between impairments and disablism. Thomas described social-relational factors of two main types: psycho-emotional factors and impairment effects.  

Psycho-emotional factors refer to everyday interactions, cultural representations, and organisational practices that cumulatively undermine the emotional wellbeing, sense of identity and self-esteem of people with impairments. According to this view, a person with an impairment receives repeated messages of devaluation, exclusion or of inferiority, and over time these become internalised. This internalised view then limits this person’s capacity to contribute to society through a diminished confidence, sense of self-worth, or person’s own belief in their right to participate. Thomas argues that disablism as a cause of disability is therefore best understood as encompassing these psycho-emotional effects alongside the more widely understood structural barriers. 

Impairment effects include experiences such as chronic pain, fatigue, reduced mobility, sensory loss or other bodily constraints that cannot be wholly explained by societal oppression and instead are the consequences of the impairment itself. By incorporating impairment effects in her framework, Thomas puts forward a more holistic view that recognises disability as a combination of the embodied reality of living with impairments as well as the disabling consequences of societal exclusion and oppression. 

Another prominent disability rights advocate, Tom Shakespeare, also heavily influenced the social-relational model. Shakespeare views disability as a complex interaction between a person with an impairment and society ​[26]​​ [27]​. He notes that different types of impairments lead to different experiences of disability. For instance, people with sensory impairments, such as Deaf people, or communication impairments, such as Autistic people, may experience disability very differently to people with a mobility impairment because communication, identity and culture are differentially important to these experiences.  

Additionally, Shakespeare highlights that certain disability models were developed primarily by those with physical impairments and so they do not well capture the experiences of people with either development or acquired intellectual impairments. 

Finally, Shakespeare points out the limitations of both the medical and the social models in accounting for the cause of disability in people whose impairments are progressive, such as motor neuron disease, or fluctuating, such as multiple sclerosis. For progressive impairments, the extent to which these impact a person’s capacity to participate in society increases over time and this increase occurs regardless of whether the society is broadly inclusive and accessible. For intermittent impairments, it means it is not feasible for the individual themselves, or for society, to anticipate when, and at what magnitude, an accommodation is required.  

These conditions highlight that disability cannot be purely characterised as social oppression or as the presence or absence of a given impairment. Instead, he argues that these different disability experiences by people with these different types of impairments require disability to be understood as an outcome of a complex inter-relationship between individual characteristics, an impairment or another individual trait, and contextual factors, a specific barrier or broader economic, cultural, social or political factors ​[19]​.  

The social-relational and biopsychosocial models share the understanding that disability is best understood by considering the interaction between individual factors and environmental context. The social-relational model is broader in focus; it does not require impairment to be understood from a health perspective. For instance, a biopsychosocial model may be useful in thinking about the relationship between a progressive health condition, such as Parkinson’s Disease, and disability. However, the social-relational model also considers the relationship between an impairment that is not a health condition, such as being born with limb differences, and disability. 

Measuring disability in a survey using this approach would again involve asking people to report if they, firstly, have an impairment and secondly, have limitations in their ability to participate in certain activities. The distinction between this approach, and the social model questions explained above, is that the limitation question should allow for people to report limitations that are either a result of oppression from a person, group or organisation or where the limitation may result, in their view, from psycho-emotional factors or impairment effects. That is, a person would be categorised as disabled if they report a condition that meets the definition of impairment used, for example, a limb amputation, so long as they report a limitation in their ability to partake in some aspect of society. The reason for that limitation can be reported by this person as oppression, such as, a building is not accessible for their wheelchair, or a consequence of the impairment itself, such as, chronic pain, or both.