Categorising a person as disabled or not disabled is not straightforward. Disability is one word, but it has multiple related, but distinct meanings. The fact that disability can mean different things to different people presents a challenge when asking people in a survey whether they are disabled. For disability data to have value and inform policy, we must be clear on what is the underlying concept we are trying to capture via the data collection. Below, we expand, with some examples, on how disability is defined in each of the different meanings of the word.
Disability can be an identity, and for some people being disabled is central to their identity. For others, disability may be secondary to other identity traits, such as, gender identity, or their ethnicity. Others may meet some disability definitions but may not identify as disabled. Importantly, when considering data collection, aspects of a person’s identity can be fluid. They are not always fixed or static over the course of a person’s life. The relative importance of being disabled may therefore change for a person over time.
Asking a person whether they identify as disabled may depend on when this question is put to them, such as before or after a clinical assessment or, for example, at the early stages of having acquired a progressive condition such as motor neuron disease, relative to the later stages.
Whether someone identifies as disabled may also be influenced by the point in time that person is asked the question based on their set of circumstances at the time of being asked. For instance, someone may report no disability at a time in life when they have abundant family support, are employed and enjoy rewarding relationships. The same person may report a disabled identity a short time later if some of these circumstances have changed for them. Self-identifying as disabled can also be dependent on situational context. For example, a wheelchair user may not identify as disabled in an accessible building but could answer the question differently while considering their experience accessing a building with steps and no accessible entry.
More broadly, disability can also be a political, social, or cultural identity. Someone with hearing loss who is an active member of the Deaf community may view themselves as culturally Deaf but not disabled. For some disabled people, the disabled identity they experience is a response to their desire to bring about change in attitudes, policy or services. For instance, a person may identify as a disabled person, as a member of the disability community and as a member of a disability rights movement, and these are each important to their personal identity.
Disability is defined in several pieces of Irish legislation. The Irish statute book does not employ a single, universal definition or contextual description of disability. Instead, disability is defined in multiple legislative instruments, and of critical importance is the fact that these disability definitions differ from each other and from international comparators in important ways. This has implications for understanding the extent to which disability, as measured in surveys, captures the same or different concepts to those defined in each legal sense of the word. Each Irish statutory definition is outlined, in brief, below.
Section 2 of the Employment Equality Acts 1998 – 2015 [6] defines disability as:
“the total or partial absence of a person's bodily or mental functions… and shall be taken to include a disability which exists at present, or which previously existed… or which may exist in the future or which is imputed to a person.”
Section 2(1) of the Equal Status Act 2000 [7] defines disability as:
“the total or partial absence of a person's bodily or mental functions… the presence in the body of organisms causing, or likely to cause, chronic disease or illness… the malfunction, malformation or disfigurement of a part of a person's body… a condition or malfunction which results in a person learning differently… or a condition, disease or illness which affects a person's thought processes, perception of reality, emotions or judgement or which results in disturbed behaviour.”
It is worth noting that the definition is set out in the Equal Status Act in similar terms as in the Employment Equality Acts, but in the case of the Equal Status Act, the explicit reference to past, future or imputed disability is made through interpretation and case law rather than repeated verbatim in every section.
Section 2 of the Disability Act 2005 [8] defines disability as:
“a substantial restriction in the capacity of the person to carry on a profession… or to participate in social or cultural life… by reason of an enduring… impairment.”
Part 2 of the Disability Act 2005 further defines ‘substantial restriction’ for part 2 as a restriction which
Section 210 of the Social Welfare Consolidation Act 2005 [9] defines disability as:
“substantially restricted in undertaking employment… suited to that person’s age, experience and qualifications.”
The Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act 2015 [10] does not specifically define disability, it instead adopts a functional approach to describe capacity limitations, which by definitions in other statutes would be constituted as disability.
Section 52 of The Education for People with Special Education Needs (EPSEN) Act 2004 [11] defines a special educational need as:
“a restriction in the capacity of the person to participate in and benefit from education on account of an enduring physical, sensory, mental health or learning disability, or any other condition which results in a person learning differently from a person without that condition and cognate words shall be construed accordingly.”
The term special educational need (SEN) applies to people who have conditions that impact learning. This would include people with and without disabilities, but SEN is not a direct synonym for disability.
Each state defines disability in its own domestic federal or provincial laws, which have slightly different definitions. These differences present challenges where international comparison is concerned.
This Strategy focuses on ensuring that persons with disabilities can fully participate in society, on an equal basis with others, taking account of the diversity of disability comprising long-term physical, mental, intellectual or sensory impairments, which are often invisible [12].
This Convention defines persons with disabilities as “those who have long-term physical, mental, intellectual or sensory impairments which in interaction with various barriers may hinder their full and effective participation in society on an equal basis with others” [13].
Disability is also a term used in many publicly funded services. Here, we outline some of the ways in which disability is defined and understood in those contexts. The definitions of disability applied by these services sometimes relies on statutory definitions that overlap across different service types, but sometimes different statutory or non-statutory definitions are applied inconsistently across services. These differences can present challenges for disability measurement and for the application of a single source of disability data to each of these contexts.
In healthcare, disability is understood as a reduction in a person’s functional ability in any given scenario on account of the interactions between their physical or mental health condition(s), other personal factors and external contextual factors. The application of a biopsychosocial model to understand the interplay between health and disability is formally set out by the WHO in the ICF, outlined in more detail in Section 4 of this report. As such, in healthcare, generally disability is not a term for a binary or stable category, where a person can be categorised as disabled or non-disabled and where this definition always applies in all contexts. However, in Ireland, the Disability Act 2005 does view disability as a binary and stable categorisation and if the person was born on, or after 01 June 2002, an assessment of need (AoN) is the process used to determine if a person meets this statutory definition. While this is a statutory process that goes beyond healthcare provision, the AoN process may involve diagnostic assessment by healthcare professionals, and it may yield a service statement which includes health services. Therefore, in Irish healthcare, disability is defined both as a non-binary and fluid concept, defined in the ICF, and as a binary and stable concept, defined in the Disability Act 2005. Also, healthcare services, like other public sectors, also have non-discrimination responsibilities, defined in equality law.
In social care, the Disability Act 2005 provides the legislative basis for assessing needs and determining appropriate services. In Ireland more broadly, social care policy is influenced by Ireland’s commitments to the UNCRPD and places disability within a human rights framework and focuses on inclusion, participation, autonomy and independent living [14] [2]. In social care services, therefore, disability is defined using both a broad rights-based understanding and a more narrowly defined categorisation for service eligibility based on assessed need. As above, social care services have responsibilities in equality law.
In education, the EPSEN Act does not directly define disability, but certain types of disability are used in its definition of special educational needs (SEN). To understand the meaning of disability in an educational context, it is useful to consider those who are disabled but who do not meet the definition of SEN (such as, a wheelchair user) and those who meet both definitions (such as, someone with an intellectual disability). Educational institutions must have regard to their obligations under equality law to disabled students without SEN but the EPSEN Act places additional responsibilities on these institutions for those who also meet the definition of SEN. Note, there are also students who have SEN, but who may not meet a formal definition of disability. These separate, but overlapping, constructs can cause confusion when measuring or using disability data in educational services.
In other sectors of public service delivery, disability is understood through equality law and or through the Disability Act 2005. That is, many public services have responsibilities not to discriminate against disabled people with respect to the services they provide or oversee. These include, for example, accessible transport or housing, access to information from public bodies, employment, justice and the right to participate in democratic, leisure or other societal processes.